ESS Topic 8.3 Solid Domestic Waste

topic 8.3: solid domestic waste

image from www.scrd.ca

Domestic solid waste, commonly known as trash or garbage (US), refuse or rubbish(UK) is a waste type consisting of everyday items that are discarded by the public. The organic waste potions consist of food and kitchen waste, yard trimmings or other garden waste. Inorganic waste consists of paper, corrugated cardboard, plastic, glass, wood, and metal products such as drink cans.

In this unit we will look at your contribution to domestic waste as well as the waste contributed by our community. We will also look at different management strategies in dealing with domestic waste.

This unit is a minimum of 3 hours.

Significant Ideas

Solid domestic waste (SDW) is increasing as a result of growing human populations and consumption
Both the production and management of SDW can have significant influence on sustainability

Big questions:

What strengths and weaknesses of the systems approach and the use of models have been revealed through this topic?
To what extend have the solutions emerging from this topic been directed at preventing environmental impacts, limiting the extent of the environmental impacts, or restoring systems in which environmental impacts have already occurred?
What value systems can you identify at play in the causes an approaches to resolving the issues addressed in this topic?
How does your own value system compare with others you have encountered in the context of issues raised in this topic?
How are the issues addressed in this topic of relevance to sustainability or sustainable development?
In what ways might the solutions explored in this topic alter your predictions for the state of human societies and the biosphere some decades from now?
How do models and/or a systems approach help our understanding of solid domestic waste/
Evaluate the alternatives for the disposal of solid domestic waste.
How do environmental value systems influence the disposal of solid domestic waste?
What are your views on this?
Examine the relationship between solid domestic waste and sustainability
How is solid domestic waste likely to change over the next few decades? Give reasons for your answer.

Knowledge and Understanding:

8.3.U1 There are different types of SDW, the volume and composition of which changes over time
[SDW includes household waste such as paper, glass, metal, plastics, organic (kitchen or garden) packaging, construction debris, and clothing]

Define solid domestic waste
List examples of solid domestic waste
Describe and explain the changes in the volume and composition of SDW over time

Human activities produce a wide range of waste from an equally wide range of activities.Solid domestic waste is the waste generated from households. This does not include industrial waste that is produced from industrial processes This material can be made up of:

paper
cardboard
metal, glass
plastics
e-waste
household chemicals

Garbage: the four broad categories:

Organic waste: kitchen waste, vegetables, flowers, leaves, fruits.
Toxic waste: old medicines, paints, chemicals, bulbs, spray cans, fertilizer and pesticide containers, batteries, shoe polish.
Recyclable: paper, glass, metals, plastics.
Soiled: hospital waste such as cloth soiled with blood and other body fluids.

image from Shanghai American School

8.3.U2 The abundance and prevalence of non-biodegradable pollution (such as plastic, batteries or e-waste) in particular has become a major environmental issue.

Explain why the prevalence of non-biodegradable pollution (such as plastic, batteries, or e-waste) has become a major environmental issue.

image from https://www.pinterest.com/aquaventuremlt/save-our-oceans

As we become more technologically advanced, we produce materials that can withstand extreme temperatures, are durable and easy to use. Plastic bags, synthetics, plastic bottles, tin cans, and computer hardware- these are some of the things that make life easy for us.

Non-biodegradable waste is a type of waste that can not be broken down into its base compounds by micro-organisms, air, moisture or soil in a reasonable amount of time. Non-biodegradable waste is an environmental concern, as it threatens to overwhelm landfills and create disposal problems.

image from https://blogs.anderson.ucla.edu/global-supply-chain/2014/08/win-win-win-in-e-waste-management.html

For many years, most manufacturers and production facilities have operated using a linear economy. This ‘take, make, dispose’ method of manufacturing means that instead of recycling the raw materials and any waste associated with the production process, they are disposed of instead.

Not only does a linear economy product a huge amount of unwanted, and sometimes dangerous landfill waste, it also puts a lot of pressure on the country’s plummeting resources as new raw materials need to be found and utilized

https://www.instarmac.co.uk/linear-vs-circular-economy/

8.3.U3 Waste disposal options include landfills, incineration, recycling and composting

Discuss the waste disposal options - landfill, incineration, recycling and composting.

There are eight major groups of waste management methods, each of them divided into numerous categories. Those groups include source reduction and reuse, animal feeding, recycling, composting, fermentation, landfills, incineration and land application. You can start using many techniques right at home, like reduction and reuse, which works to reduce the amount of disposable material used

Landfills - Throwing daily waste/garbage in the landfills is the most popularly used method of waste disposal used today. This process of waste disposal focuses attention on burying the waste in the land.
Incineration/Combustion - a type disposal method in which municipal solid wastes are burned at high temperatures so as as to convert them into residue and gaseous products. The biggest advantage of this type of method is that it can reduce the volume of solid waste to 20 to 30 percent of the original volume, decreases the space they take up and reduce the stress on landfills.
Recovery and Recycling - process of taking useful discarded items for a specific next use. These discarded items are then processed to extract or recover materials and resources or convert them to energy in the form of useable heat, electricity or fuel.
Composting - a easy and natural bio-degradation process that takes organic wastes i.e. remains of plants and garden and kitchen waste and turns into nutrient rich food for your plants.

8.3.U4 There are a variety of strategies that can be used to manage SDW (reference to figure 3) influenced by cultural, economic, technological and political barriers. There strategies include 1) altering human activity - for example, through a reduction of consumption and composting of food waste, 2) controlling the release of pollutant - governments create legislation to encourage recycling and reuse initiative and impose taxes for SDW collection and on disposable items, 3) reclaiming landfills, using SDW for waste to energy programs implementing initiatives to remove plastics from the Great Pacific garage patch (clean-up and restoration)

Compare and contrast the various pollution management strategies for SDW.
Discuss the impact of culture, economics, technology and political attitudes on the choice of SDW management strategies employed by a society.

Pollution management strategies that should be considered are recycling, incineration, composting and landfill.

Cause
Reduce - Reduce packaging
Reuse - Choose second hand materials or reusable containers
Recycle - Choose materials that can be recycled
Composting - Organic can be composted at source. Choose biodegradable materials

Effect
Incineration - Easy and Quick. Releases greenhouse gases such as methane which could be used for powering but can produce toxic pollutants
Landfill - Might pollute groundwater through leeching. We are facing less available space
Sealed landfill - Prevent leeching but higher costs. There is limited space
Composting - Can turn organic wastes into resources

Application and skills:

8.3.A1 Evaluate SDW disposal options

Strategies for dealing with SDW:

Composting

Advantages

Disadvantages

Reduces amount of waste in landfills
Low cost
Composting can be done at the commercial and industrial levels, but also on a household level
Creates fertile soils
Decrease the use of synthetic fertilizers (which has it’s own environmental issues it causes)
Improves soil porosity and water retention

If not done correctly can attract pests
Requires public buy in
Only for organic matter
Windrow and aerated static pile composting require relatively large areas, and odor control is a common problem.
Residential composting bins can get very dirty, and be hard to clean
Amount of effort involved. All the materials must be carried to the compost pile,

Recycling

Advantages

Prevents the loss of useful raw materials.
Reduces the consumption of new raw materials.
Reduces energy usage in some areas (though collection and processing does use energy).
Creates Green jobs
Reduces pollution at the extraction phase of the process - getting the raw materials out of the ground.
Lowers the release of greenhouse gases.
materials are collected, separated, and processed first. Success depends on how much energy and raw materials are required to produce the material in the first place.
plastics
glass can be melted and re-shaped into new bottles or jars indefinitely; this requires less energy than making new bottles and jars
paper
metals (aluminum is most common and cost-effective material for recycling; steel is also frequently recycled

Disadvantages

Requires public buy in
Not always cost effective
Building up a new waste recycling unit takes up a lot of capital.
Products may not be as durable. These kinds of products are almost always made of trashed waste material collected from other waste materials that have been overly utilized and fragile. This makes products of recycled waste less durable and low priced.
Locations where every manner of waste is piled provides a nice ground for the formation of debris and spread of infectious diseases

Incineration

Advantages

SDW burned at very high temperatures. Very useful for clinical waste and any hazardous waste containing pathogens
Landfill space is running out. Incineration can burn up to 90% of the total waste generated in a chosen area
Dioxin emissions from incineration have been reduced with new technology.
Can be used to produce electricity (‘waste-to-energy’ plants)
Takes up much less space than landfills.
Reduces the volume of waste by 80 – 85% therefore it is very popular in countries where land is scarce e.g. Japan.
Used to generate local district heating. Sweden generates 8% of its heating needs from waste incinerators..
Can function in any type of weather
Bottom ash can be recycled and used to build roads
Avoids the methane emissions of landfills.
Incineration doesn’t add any toxic elements to the groundwaterIncineration plants retrieve metal form the ashes and this can then be recycled.
Nutrients returned to soils in agriculture, parks, or home gardens
Already used on large-scale basis in many MEDC
Many people in LEDC’s live on the tips and make a living sifting through the waste. Incinerators take away this livelihood.

Disadvantages

Toxic fly ash is difficult to dispose of safely and adds waste miles (distance the waste is transported) as it is moved to landfills.
Emits smoke from the chimneys includes nitrogen oxide, particulates, heavy metals, acid gases and the carcinogen dioxin.
May produce dioxins and heavy metal deposits from materials burned
New incinerators are taking away the funding from other renewable energy research and development.
Old incinerators emit dioxin and furan. These are toxic gases which have been cited as being carcinogenic.
Causes property devaluation in the surrounding areas.
Causes visual pollution due to the intrusive chimney stack.
There are some concerns as to the safety levels of bottom ash and the UK Highway Authority has banned its use in concrete work.
Filters do not remove the finest particles from air emissions.
Set up costs are very high.

Landfills

Advantages

Primary way SDW is disposed of
Initially cheap, but costs increasing rapidly as sites fill up
Methane from decomposition may be captured for energy production. Used to generate local district heating in Denmark and Sweden.
Old landfill sites can be landscaped and re-used for building projects.
Creates jobs for the local community - though they are usually unskilled and low paid jobs
Landfill sites that are close to settlements reduce the cost of transporting the waste

Disadvantages

Landfill sites give off dangerous gases that cause air pollution and global warming (methane). There is also the potential for explosions if methane is allowed to build up.
Liners can fail and leachate leak into the local environment and groundwater sources.
Settling after compaction can cause problems for future uses – must be left a long time to settle fully.
Most landfill sites close to populations are full so waste collection vehicles have to travel a long way to alternative sites.
Landfills are filling up. Even with daily compaction of waste the life span of landfills is limited.
Poorly managed sites cause problems with vectors such as rats, mice and flies increasing the spread of diseases.
Heavy vehicles cause traffic problems and damage local roads.
Poorly managed sites cause problems with dust, odor, visual and noise pollution - these can negatively impact local property prices in the area.
Contribute to marine debris - the litter that ends up in seas and oceans as it blows off poorly managed sites.

8.3.A2 Compare and contrast pollution management strategies for SDW

8.3.A3 Evaluate, with reference to figure 3, pollution management strategies for SDW by considering recycling, incineration, composting and landfills.
[Students should consider the amount and source of non-biodegradable pollution generated within a chosen locality and how it is managed]

Human activity

reduce consumption
compost food waste
reduce packing
reuse clothes/goods

Controlling release

separate wastes into different types
legislate recycling
education about recycling
tax SDW

Clean-up and Restoration

reclaim landfills
use incineration for energy production
collect plastics/discarded from the environment

Key Terms

solid domestic waste
upcycling
humus
diseases
trash-to-energy
linear economy

incineration
composting
hazardous waste
sanitary landfill
biodegradable
reuse

landfill
vericomposting
mercury
chemicals
inert
repurpose

composting
wasteful
methane
organic waste
circular economy
WEEE

recycling
leachate
community
e-waste
reduce

Classroom Materials

Case Studies

Detailed examples of the pros & cons of the 4 main types of solid domestic waste disposal options (landfills, incinerators, composting, the 6Rs)

Powerpoint and Notes Adapted from Brad Kremer and PBrooks

Correct use of terminology is a key skill in ESS. It is essential to use key terms correctly when communicating your understanding, particularly in assessments. Use the quizlet flashcards or other tools such as learn, scatter, space race, speller and test to help you master the vocabulary.

Useful Links

Topic 8.3 Solid Domestic Waste - NicheScience
What a Waste: An Updated Look into the Future of Solid Waste Management

Urban Environmental and Waste Management - Urban Environmental Management
Municipal Solid Waste - EPA
Composition of Waste in the UK - Marden Edwards Journal
Solid Waste - Learner
Composting - Planet Nature
Waste Generation Scheme - Grida
How Landfills Work - How Stuff Works
Recycling Facts - Recycling Revolution
Hazardous Waste Nat Geo: Half Life Dealing with Nuclear Waste

In The News
More than 1.5 billion masks believed to have entered oceans in 2020, The Denver Channel, 24 Dec 2020
How Big Oil and Big Soda kept a global environmental calamity a secret for decades, Rolling Stone, 3 March 2020
Solar Panel Waste: The Dark Side of Clean Energy, Discover, 14 Dec 2020
Plastic To Dust - Science Daily 12 May 2014
NASA Warms Up To Maryland's Trash - NASA 8 May 2003
More Emphasis Needed on Recycling and Reuse of Li-ion Batteries - Science Daily 22 May 2013
eWaste - National Geographic Jan 2008

International-mindedness:

Pollution can be transborder, the pollution from one country may affect another
Differences in development level of countries can influence the amount and type of SDW they generate

TOK

The circular economy can be seen as a paradigm shift-does knowledge develop through paradigm shifts in all areas of knowledge?

Video Clips

Trashed - No Place For Waste with the participation of Jeremy Irons, looks at the risks to the food chain and the environment through pollution of our air, land, and sea by waste. The film reveals surprising truths about very immediate and potent dangers to our health

It's time to get back out into the world because online shopping is killing us, psychologically and environmentally.

The basics of sustainable waste management in animated form, produced for the Östergötland County Council in Sweden, for the "Waste To Energy" EU project.

A powerful documentary about the dumping of toxic computer wastes on developing nations, specifically Guiyu, China

Waste is directly linked to human development, both technologically and socially. The composition of different waste has varied over time and location with the connection between waste materials and industrial development and innovation

Where do all our easy and free online returns really end up? We bought products from Amazon and then returned them with tracking devices hidden inside to follow the trail. Next, we posed as buyers in the lucrative liquidation marketplace where we bid on a truckload of returned products. How much can we resell compared to what will get trashed?

There's a world of opportunity to re-think and re-design the way we make stuff. 'Re-Thinking Progress' explores how through a change in perspective we can re-design the way our economy works - designing products that can be 'made to be made again' and powering the system with renewable energy. It questions whether with creativity and innovation we can build a restorative economy

Economic growth across developing Asian countries has led to a sharp increase in consumption. With higher levels of waste now generated, local governments struggle to cope with solid waste management

Ever wonder how the landfill gas-to-energy process works? This video takes you through how Waste Management converts naturally occurring landfill gas into clean renewable energy at its LFGTE facilities across the country.

The Great Pacific Garbage Patch is a massive dump of floating garbage in the Pacific Ocean. We contribute to it everyday by littering and using un-biodegradable materials. Our trash is taken downstream from rivers into the ocean, where currents sweep it to the closest patch.

Commercial waste recycling in Devon, U.K.

This talk was given at a local TEDx event, produced independently of the TED Conferences. It's hard to comprehend the amount of plastic waste humans produce every single day. But the impact is impossible to ignore. However, the answer is not recycling -- it's reuse

It’s important for everyone to go green and work together in creating a sustainable future. One of the best ways to help save Mother Earth is to recycle. But it’s not always easy to tell what can and can’t be recycled, especially when it comes to plastic. You’re probably wondering: What do the numbers on plastic mean? What numbers of plastic are recyclable

Rajan Ahluwalia has been in the recycling business since 1989. He is from Mumbai (Bombay) India

18-year-old Boyan Slat combines environmentalism, entrepreneurism and technology to tackle global issues of sustainability.

Lauren is an Environmental Studies graduate from NYU and former Sustainability Manager at the NYC Department of Environmental Protection, and the amount of trash that she has produced over the past three years can fit inside of a 16 oz. mason jar.

San Francisco diverts 80% of its waste from landfills, more than any other major city in North America. It hopes to achieve zero waste by 2020. Here's a look at what makes the city's waste management system so successful.

Engineer Toby McCartney explains how his Scottish start-up MacRebur is persuading councils to use local waste plastic to build roads. Two English councils have already started building roads this way.